Most of the time I prefer to share content I enjoyed here, but the reality is that not every sequel is going to please everyone, and I’d be lying if I said that I didn’t experience some major disappointments from time to time. To the point, an unliked BD is generally trivial and forgettable, but something which you’d been looking forward to hurts much worse.
I found I Am Their Silence to be a quirky, energetic, effective murder-mystery. Very interesting to see main character Eva Rojas be a gifted psychiatrist who’s also thoroughly bipolar. She also hallucinates three of her dead family members, who can be alternately helpful or hugely annoying. The result was quite a unique, fun experience for me:
Earlier review here:
https://piefed.social/post/1231330
And a formal one, with more sample pages in French:
https://www.bdgest.com/preview-3916-BD-un-polar-a-barcelone-recit-complet.html
Unfortunately I found the follow-up album I’m a Lost Angel to be… pretty terrible indeed. Eva’s formerly hilarious quirkiness devolved in to a far more annoying ‘main character syndrome,’ and Jordi Lefebre’s formerly deft ability to weave together an improbably great story turned in to a case of pure self-indulgence, with virtually every area of the story worse than the one before. TBH, part of this is just “Jordi being Jordi,” in which he routinely renders his characters as overly precious and Disney-esque, but I liked the first album as an exception to that rule, more or less.
Negalyod T1 was the first work I’d read of Vincent Perriot, and while I felt it had some logistical problems, on the whole it was an above-average sci-fi story with some interesting commentary on the human condition and civilisation’s tendency to eventually topple itself. The art was pretty neat – not quite Moebius level – but was fairly original and unique-looking in a dingy - grungy kind of way.
https://www.bedetheque.com/BD-Negalyod-Tome-1-340430.html
Unfortunately, I found tome two to be a complete mess. It dealt with the aftermath of the ‘global threat’ being brought down in the first book, in which the planet became radically transformed, with raging oceans and threats from above, and… I’m not sure what else. Via page after page, we got huge splashies with little context, story-flow or character development, and the satisfying linear development of tome one was completely abandoned. Well, that’s what I got from the first ~100pp anyway, when I gave up out of frustration.
I’d be curious if any of the readers here have had similar experiences with Euro comics they’d been looking forward to.
johnnyenzyme@piefed.social@piefed.social