I think the third episode was where I really fell off. I think Madoka is unique in that I couldn’t bring myself to say it was bad, so I just left it as an unscored drop on my AniList, with the caveat that said drop isn’t exactly a statement about the show’s quality, but more that the show (and really most Shaft shows) just don’t strike my fancy. The lone exception as yet has been 3-Gatsu no Lion, which is absolutely fucking fantastic.