Yeah we probably agree more than disagree. I just see taxing sin being a cop out that leaves all the harm of privatisation, all the harm of regressive taxation and corruption of peverse incentives, and then cops out on the social responsibility by going “we’re already beating you poors with the stick, what more could you want from us!?”

Defs if it was government run as harm minimisation (which incidentally is what I’d like to see done for alcohol and other drugs) it shouldn’t be done in a way which does not promote or glorify it but also doesn’t shame people for wanting to do it. Just try not to get people hooked (or perhaps: not try to get people hooked) and offer non judgemental and non patronising assistance for those who want to stop or limit themselves.