Comment on XMPP as a Discord alternative for small group?
LodeMike@lemmy.today 5 months agoDoes XMPP not have the same metadata?
Comment on XMPP as a Discord alternative for small group?
LodeMike@lemmy.today 5 months agoDoes XMPP not have the same metadata?
poVoq@slrpnk.net 5 months ago
No, or rather not quite. XMPP is designed on a need-to-see system where basically only the meta-data that a server or client really requires to function is shared with it. This can mean that there is quite a bit of meta-data shared with various servers in a popular group-chat, but that is rather the exception.
Matrix on the other hand is designed as a replicated data-store, meaning that really everything is shared with every connected server by design. The reason for this is so that chats can continue to function even when the original server is removed etc. This was the big original selling point of Matrix, but lately they have been somewhat quiet about it as it largely contradicts privacy concerns and might even be fundamentally GDPR incompatible. In any case it is pretty much a meta-data nightmare.
LodeMike@lemmy.today 5 months ago
Well you also can’t remove shit on someone else’s email servers so is that not GDPR compatible?
poVoq@slrpnk.net 5 months ago
In the case of email you have to actively send something to someone for it to be on their server. In Matrix it is sufficient for a 3rd party to join a chat for them to get the entire chat history (hopefully e2ee) including all meta-data back to the very first day the chat was created.
LodeMike@lemmy.today 5 months ago
They’re actually working on that.
TCB13@lemmy.world 5 months ago
Let me add the following: the problem is that that metadata is all over the place AND you can’t remove it from those 3rd party servers. Also there’s a ton of questionable stuff like read receipts and reactions that are never encrypted (not sure if this was fixed already). XMPP with OMEMO enables will encrypt everything.
poVoq@slrpnk.net 5 months ago
Currently the OMEMO as implemented in most clients only encrypts message content, but not the meta-data. There is a newer, sadly incompatible version that encrypts more, but few XMPP clients support it.