Comment

Comment on Passkeys might really kill passwords

there’s nothing you have to remember which makes it more convenient for you to use

Unlike my devices, I always have my brain on me. Devices are much more easily lost or stolen than memories. I often might want to access sites using my account from third party devices which I don’t want to be able to use my accounts when I’m not using them.

I just can’t understand how using passkeys (or password managers, for that matter, massive single points of failure that they are) is supposed to be in any way shape or form more convenient than simply remembering a passphrase (which can easily be customisable for each site using some simple formula so that no two sites will share the same but it’ll still be trivial to remember).

Both password managers and passkeys seem like colossal inconveniences and security risks to me when compared to passphrases, frankly. And if you want extra security there’s always two factor authentication (with multiple alternatives in case you don’t have access to one of them, of course; otherwise you might as well delete your account).

source

Sort:hotnew top

subtext@lemmy.world ⁨8⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

Both password managers and passkeys seem like colossal inconveniences

Both my mom and my grandma who are extremely far from tech literate absolutely love that I forced them into using a password manager because it is so much more convenient.

My mom wouldn’t even do the special algorithm for each site, she just had like 2 or 3 passwords that she would use depending on site requirements, and even that simple setup was far less convenient for her than a password manager. She was the one who initially had the idea to make my grandma use one because she became evangelized about how much better a password manager is than having to remember passwords.

Your point about inconvenience is just straight up wrong.

I would also vehemently disagree with your claim that they are a security risk unless you just straight up use them wrong / use hunter2 as your master password. But this comment is already super long so I will just stop there.

source
Crogdor@lemmy.world ⁨8⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
Coming up with a simple formula is a big security risk. It makes your passwords easier to brute force, and with enough entropy, probably easy to guess as well.

And what happens if the password is breached? Do you change the formula? What happens if a site requires a password change? Even if the formula accounts for versioning/iterating, how do you remember which iteration you’re on?

Extra security with 2FA I agree with, but that’s not mutually exclusive to using a password manager.

And are password managers really single points of failure? These password managers can sync to multiple devices, so your data is generally safe. If someone gets your password manager password, that’s a problem, yes, but they’d need access to your device to view anything, as installing on another device requires a separate master key to set it all up (which should not be stored digitally anywhere).

source
- leftzero@lemmynsfw.com ⁨8⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  
  It makes your passwords easier to brute force
  
  Passphrases are by definition hard to brute force.
  
  The formula should not be obvious. Don’t just put the site’s name in the passphrase, put a similar sounding but easy to remember word, something that rhymes, the first and last letters of the site’s name plus the number of letters in the domain name, whatever.
  
  An attacker would need to specifically target you and have more than one of your passphrases using the same formula in order to try to figure it out. Too much work. If they’re that interested in your password it’s easier to beat you up until you tell them.
  
  And what happens if the password is breached? Do you change the formula? What happens if a site requires a password change?
  
  You can have a couple different formulas or variations.
  
  how do you remember which iteration you’re on?
  
  Same way you’d remember the password you used for a site if you reused two or three different passwords.
  
  And if you use the wrong one just try again; sure, passphrases can be a bit long, but having to type them multiple times is a good way to make sure you remember which one you used, lest you have to type it again.
  
  source
degrix@lemmy.hqueue.dev ⁨8⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
The benefit of passkeys over passwords is that they’re phishing resistant and use strong encryption. They’re effectively an iteration on yubikeys meaning you can have as many (or as few) passkeys associated with a given login as you’d like. So, you can easily prevent there being a single point of failure in the system.

Passkeys are tied to accounts and devices and those devices are the only devices used for authentication. This means you can access your account form a public device without that device ever knowing your credentials provided you and your secure device are physically present so it avoids the whole keylogger issue.

source
- leftzero@lemmynsfw.com ⁨8⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  
  This means you can access your account form a public device without that device ever knowing your credentials provided you and your secure device are physically presen
  
  My secure device is in my other pants, though. I misplace my brain much less often.
  
  source