Oof, going to have to trim my favorites (story, single-player) simply for the replay value ones.

1. Minecraft: been a decade or so but the open-ended style means almost infinite replay value.
2. Cyberpunk 2077: Just love the lore and world. I have over 1k hours, another 1k won’t be hard. With mods, even more.
3. Metal Gear Solid Master Collection 1: These games are ridiculous and I love them.
4. RDR2: Story-based but I can kill a LOT of time just by not rushing. Lovely game.
5. Stardew Valley: So much replay value, so much to do in one playthrough alone. Easy pick.
6. Minesweeper: Great for killing small amounts of time.
7. Timberborn: Scratch that colony sim itch.
8. Subnautica: scratch that survival-craft itch.
9. Balatro: for variety i guess. Enjoy it well enough.
10. Sekiro: Haven’t finished but I need a hard skill check for when im feeling masochistic.

Runner Up: Mass Effect trilogy LE. Fantastic games, and I need that space itch scratched too. Bumped for genre variety reasons.