Comment

Comment on Protecting HDDs from (external) train vibrations

randy@lemmy.ca ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

None of the included experiments look to be exactly what you need. For characterizing your isolator, the included Acceleration Spectrum is close, though it records continuously, making it difficult to use to record impact response. For evaluating actual train vibrations, the user-defined Integrated Acceleration might be a start, but it doesn’t include the filtering needed to get good information. You could define your own experiments, but that’s probably even harder than analyzing the CSV data on your computer. At least on your computer you can change your analysis freely and immediately see results, rather than re-running the experiment every time.

source

Sort:hotnew top

khorak@lemmy.dbzer0.com ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
I’ve been a bit busy so I haven’t had the time to figure out what and how much I need to compensate so the sensor data is more useful. One of the sensors seems to be detecting something reminiscent of a sine curve, so this will involve some extra high school math to find a function to cancel it out. Busy dad etc, maybe next week. In the mean time I started putting together the case and ordered the springy subwoofer legs. Here is how a simple plot of the raw acceleration looks like.

It’s obvious which one is the before and after. The second one even includes two trains arriving back to back.

Now I need to figure out a few things:

repeatable experiment (hammer? dropping something heavy from the same height?)

make the Z-axis reading more useful and compare velocities

add some foam/plywood and rubber feet on the disks

the after-graph shows barely any noticeable vibrations
source
- randy@lemmy.ca ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago
  Thanks for the update and graphs. That is an amazing improvement. In the “after” plot, it looks like any acceleration from the train is well below the noise level of your accelerometer. So, within the limits of your measuring equipment, you’ve effectively eliminated all train vibration. If I were in your place, I would declare success and move on with life! Don’t even bother with foam and rubber feet, because this configuration is working great.
  
  But you could analyze further if you really want; there could be some train signal hiding in all that noise. Since there’s periodic noise in the Z axis, you could take a reading during a still time (computer off, no trains) and see where your spikes are in the frequency domain. Then you could apply a filter (or filters) to cut out that periodic noise.
  
  But unless you’re really into learning about signal analysis, I’d say you could skip it.
  
  source