I played Starfield for around 150 hours. I went from that game to BG3. So far, I enjoyed Starfield more, but the games are so different they’re hard to compare.

Starfield was much more “turn off brain, sneak around, fight bandits” with story bits in between. I often didn’t have to put any thought into encounters if I didn’t want to. Mainly because it’s a Bethesda game, and I’ve played several before.

BG3 is slower, more methodical, with way more (and obviously better) story.

Starfield was more like comfort food, where BG3 is more like fine dining. Both great in different ways.