I do think they were really dead. The crew got a one time opportunity to make a trade and they took it, but they ignored the life they were trading away. Tuvix was always an individual I think, but it becomes more wrong to kill him the longer you let him live.
I can definitely see Tuvix being around as being traumatic. Personally, I couldn’t kill Tuvix and I think it was the wrong choice. I think even if he reminded people of their loss many would get passed it with time. A month isn’t an enough time to deal with this type of grief.
But, isolated and marooned far from home, with new enemies appearing seemingly around every corner and a small crew, you do have to sacrifice philosophical purity to survive.
Doug@midwest.social 1 year ago
I can respect your position. Even if it is wrong :)
In more seriousness though I think we’re about as close to agreeing as we’ll get. Even if a third of the crew reacted to him as I suggested long term it’s worth being part of the consideration.
It’s always nice to have a respectful disagreement. Moreso on the Internet.