It’s a matter of scale. You first try designs and concepts on a bench top scale in a lab. If that works, you scale the project up. And that scale up can reveal myriad problems. The internal heat and flow dynamics are going to change, and that may require a lot of adjustments. Specifically in this case, you may find that salt deposition is negligible at bench top scales, but when you start exploring larger units, salt ends up accumulating and causing issues. Scale up is part of the scientific process like any other, and it can end in failure unfortunately.
Comment on Desalination system could produce freshwater that is cheaper than tap water
MaroonMage@lemmy.world 1 year ago
I feel like every week we hear about some huge breakthrough that is supposed to revolutionize clean drinking water technology and save the world, but nothing ever comes of it.
I know this stuff takes time to develop, and not every idea is going to work, but it would be nice if one of these things actually did pan out and start being useful to solve our drinking water issues.
assassin_aragorn@lemmy.world 1 year ago
artic@lemmy.blahaj.zone 1 year ago
solving issues isn’t profitable
assassin_aragorn@lemmy.world 1 year ago
It’s unfortunately not a profitability issue, at least not necessarily. I wish that it was, because then all you need is investors like silicon valley and you can run at a loss.
What the researchers have created here is a bench top device. It needs to be scaled up for widespread commercial use, and that’s where things get difficult. Scale up is one of the things my field does, although I don’t have personal experience with it. Scale up is where a lot of projects die because of new issues developing.
This device is relying on flow patterns and convection currents. That gives me some concern actually, because these patterns can change a lot with larger vessels. A common industry problem with fluid flow in larger tanks is that you’ll get “dead zones”. The internal flow dynamics are such that some parts of the vessel see no actual flow, and it’s just stagnant. That’s a big problem when you’re relying on flow to keep your entire tank cool or to carry out precipitated salts.
MaroonMage@lemmy.world 1 year ago
Cool insight - thanks!
assassin_aragorn@lemmy.world 1 year ago
You’re welcome. One of the disappointing things I realized as I learned more in college wasn’t that we had easy solutions that were being suppressed by the rich, but really difficult solutions that were being discouraged by the rich.