Comment

Comment on Firefox 148 introduces the promised AI kill switch for people who aren't into LLMs

You’re defending your position that this AI feature is not really AI so it’s ok

I literally say “The translation is technically AI,” so no. I give reasons how the other features are different, which you seem to acknowledge a little, at least.

the weird gimmick you don’t understand is crucial to some

Can you describe how to access the gimmick and which people find it crucial? I’m pretty confident in my understanding of it and how hilariously unhelpful it is.

source

Sort:hotnew top

Orygin@sh.itjust.works ⁨12⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago
Being technically something implies it’s not really or to be considered apart from the group.

The “gimmick” is proposing alt text based on the image when editing PDFs. I don’t see how it’s unhelpful. I’m not into editing PDFs in firefox, but I do use it to read them.
Inciting editors to include an alt text for accessibility seems like the ideal use case for this tech. The human still has to review and approve the generated text.
Unless I missed something as I cannot try the feature now, it seems to me a great application of ai, to augment humans in their work, and to a useful cause.
Image classification and description is “old” tech now, and I already use it in my work to auto tag images for editors to find more easily later. Nothing crazy.

source
- XLE@piefed.social ⁨11⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago
  
  The “gimmick” is proposing alt text based on the image when editing PDFs. I don’t see how it’s unhelpful.
  
  A gambling toolbar that links to Polymarket could be helpful. But I think we both said “crucial”.
  
  If you know someone who uses Firefox to add images to PDFs so often that the alt text generation would be crucial to them, or even more than a gimmick, please introduce me to them. I have so many burning questions. Several things related to “why not a dedicated PDF editor?!”
  
  source
  - Orygin@sh.itjust.works ⁨2⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago
    Please never develop any software for other humans without first developing any kind of compassion or empathy for others.
    You are the stereotypical nerd that doesn’t understand people may have different needs than you, so I have to justify how a feature relating to accessibility can be useful…
    
    source