Comment on Telegram starts to look like a super app, echoing WeChat
smileyhead@discuss.tchncs.de 1 year agoBut it’s starting to get worse. Now they won’t send you an SMS code for registration unless you are using official build of the app.
This actually is not a bad thing. If an unofficial client MITM the whole registration process, it’s much harder for the true account owner to prove that he/she is the legit one.
Also, it doesn’t really require a client to register; Telegram can be accessed from a browser.
If unofficial app can MITM registration, it can the same way MITM login later.
doesn’t require a client A side note, JavaScript app in the browser is as much an app as Java/Kotlin on Android. But I know websites and web-based applications are now so mixed together it sometimes can confuse me too.
And browser version of Telegram does not allow registering new accounts also.
Compared to login, MITM on registration means the culprit knows the IP address and the time of the registration, which is usually significant on claiming the account back.
I don’t have a spare number to test, but I’m pretty sure entering a phone number in the web sends SMS. Do you have concrete evidence that it really doesn’t work?
Unfortunetly not, I must test it also.
it costs them too much to send code as sms, also some client abuse that in some way, it also may help them to increase the download count of their official app which is not bad imo.
I might be misunderstanding you, but I believe telegram requires SMS verification for all accounts, regardless of client.
What I mean is that they always require SMS code, but if you use app from F-Droid they won’t send you this code.
EngineerGaming@feddit.nl 1 year ago
One of the most egregious thing they’ve done imo is this:
As well as not allowing registration from desktop.