Comment on It's just obvious
Grail@multiverse.soulism.net 16 hours agoI worry that the belief in and pursuit of objective reality has negative social ramifications. For example, transphobia is usually motivated by a belief in objective sex. We also see racism from belief in objective race, and religious genocides such as the Crusades and the colonisation of Latin America from belief in objective religion. While we have made significant strides in all these areas recently, people have not extended the same empathy to otherkin and plural systems, still convinced of objective species and objective personhood. I fear that an antirealist approach is the only way to ensure people seek continuous progress on these issues.
ArgumentativeMonotheist@lemmy.world 14 hours ago
I think you have a very prosocial and lovely stance, and I agree with the sentiment entirely, but idk if transphobia is due to extensive knowledge of the human body, and not just an ignorant excuse for someone’s negative gut reaction/hatred, and the Crusades and South American colonization with a cross and guns was only spun with the idea of religion (really, God wills you to annihilate and subjugate peaceful people around the world?). Also, someone can and should be able to disagree with someone on non-moral stances without hating them, we should be able to live even if you consider yourself trans or otherkin and I don’t think your ideological foundation for it is valid, as long as we’re all behaving with a minimum of humanity. People should be a bit more, uh, uncertain about things though and humble because of it, certainly, as it’s not just a more valid attitude regarding our knowledge and the limits to our understanding but also the only way you can actually change your mind and progress intellectually. Idk. 🤷😅
Grail@multiverse.soulism.net 11 hours ago
You’re right that transphobes are misinformed, but what I’m opposed to is not knowledge itself. Rather, it’s the conviction that objective answers exist and can be known. Transphobes believe they have the answers to the objective nature of gender. There are no such answers. Nobody can say for certain whether another’s gender is valid, because gender is just an idea. It is the transphobes’ realism that motivates them to uphold the gender binary.
Also, Pope Urban II called for the crusades to distract Europe from internal strife among the church. Nobody should have the power to tell an entire continent what Deus wills. They believed him because they thought religion has objective answers, and that those answers come from the Pope. Again, people’s conviction that anyone can be objectively correct is what caused the problem. If Christianity were antirealist, there could be no pope and no crusades.
Truly, the belief in an objective reality is history’s greatest problem.