Comment on Portabase has been accepted into the CNCF Landscape! (open-source data backup and restore tool)
Shimitar@downonthestreet.eu 7 hours ago Lemmy is truly filled with a few but very vocal shills against AI. Which it’s their right to own as opinion of course, and indeed there are ethical issues about AI.
But whoever take such extreme stands specially on technology, which are just tools, and not against how the tools are used, it’s just wrong and harmful to the overall cause.
Solumbran@lemmy.world 4 hours ago
Some tools are inherently bad, “it’s just a tool” is just a bad faith defense.
Generative “AI” is a problem no matter how you use it, because it’s not “just a tool”, its existence causes a million moral, technical and legal issues that cannot be avoided by “using it well”.
You and the other “AI” sect members are going to do exactly like your blockchain/nft predecessors, you’ll shut up and disappear in shame when it all comes crashing down and everyone starts trying to find out who was crazy enough to fall for it. Exact same pattern, worse technology, and yet people still grasp at straws to justify how they are “one of the good ones”, then they’ll get hit by the face-eating-leopards truck that is coming at them at high speed. But heh, people still support Trump while detained by ICE, why would AI psychosis folks not do the same?
My friend, and I use the term loosely, see this is exactly what I mean.
Slurring me as part of an hypothetical “AI sect” doesn’t help anyone. Unfortunately AI is not going to disappear like all new technologies, especially the ones that are impacting all our lives so much.
Good or bad, everybody has its own opinion. I do not think AI is either good or bad. Corporate driven and environment destroying IA is bad, and I fully agree.
But the issue is not the tool, it’s how it’s used and abused, and I know here our opinions differ.
But seen here is the point: your stance is futile and doomed to insignificance, history will just draw you out, and I don’t wish you this. Instead, I suggest, humbly, you start looking into how to cope with AI, what would be a proper way to regulate it, to give it ethical guidelines, to make it open and safe.
By choice, I don’t pay or use corporate AI. I run open models on my own hardware, with PV on my roof as well. I advocate the same approach at work as well.
(Sorry, I don’t live in a fascist country, or maybe yes but a bit less fascist and more democratic than the country you are referring to)
Solumbran@lemmy.world 3 hours ago
“It won’t disappear” is exactly the sect aspect I’m mentioning. You justify not trying to stop “AI”, with the justification of “it won’t disappear”. Replace “AI” by “capitalism” or “racism” and you suddenly see why this stance is shit.
You gave in to intellectual and moral laziness and selfishness, and deluded yourself into justifying it by pretending like it’s inevitable. It’s not, but you are part of the obstacle preventing it from being eradicated. But eh, at least you can use your brain less and “waste less time” or whatever other justification you give yourself.
You are giving yourself too much leeway.
I don’t justify myself. It will not go away because it’s useful and people use it. I would be happy if racism went away, and maybe it will in due time. But it’s like comparing apples and bricks.
A technology solve a problem, and change the way the world works. In good and in bad. Sorry I cannot replace ai with racism or capitalism, those are all three different things.
And you are doing a pretty bad comparison there. One is technology, something factual, the others are ideologies. As much as you hate AI, it’s a you problem, and I am pretty sure there are many other things you hate in your life.
I feel sorry for you.