Comment on How Sony's Hawk-Eye electronic line-calling system transformed the U.S. Open
ramble81@lemm.ee 9 months agoExactly. The rule is “if the ball touches the line, it’s out” (or is outside the line, whatever) why does it matter if a human judges it or a camera?
JoBo@feddit.uk 9 months ago
If it touches the line, it is in.
It matters because humans are fallible. Machines are much more reliable in situations where there is an unambiguous right answer. That match was awful to watch and it was made worse because the TV audience could see how badly the umpire was behaving.
ramble81@lemm.ee 9 months ago
I think my point came across wrong. I was angling for the “why shouldn’t we use cameras since they’re less fallible?”, I don’t understand when people say “we need human judges because that’s more pure!” type responses.