Comment on Nexus Mods Sale Sparks Concern in Modding Community
witty_username@feddit.nl 1 day ago
Would it be possible to build a fediverse modding platform? What would that look like?
What would you federate? Would you federate posts of each mod with a link back to the home instance. Would you federate the entire modfile.
I’m not sure activity pub is the right fit here. We would lose so many mods and it would make it much harder to find mods.
Good luck hosting the terabytes of data that mods have.
Let me introduce you to torrenting and community distribution of data.
It could be implemented this way so that no one individual would need to fully shoulder the burden of hosting everything.
Federation would allow you to only host mods not hosted at other servers, with some level of redundancy.
Also, it could use a modding app with BitTorrent-like functionality, so that downloaders could share their copies as well.
So…old mods would eventually die because of zero seeders. It’s a fact of life that this would happen
I wonder if this could be solved on protocol level, i.e. automatically preserve objects with least redundancy, as known to the server.
Like if federated servers hold 50 copies of a file, it’s likely not worthy of saving, but if there is only 1 or 2, it must be stored.
Since mods are almost exclusively unable to be copyrighted nowadays, there is a very good chance the Internet Archive would be more than happy to host the mod data - as they have with many community projects.
MouldyCat@feddit.uk 1 day ago
I guess you still have the issue of someone needing to pay for the huge number of downloads, most of which are going to come from users who make no other contributions to the site. Maybe you could combine a fedi site with torrents or something?
The_Decryptor@aussie.zone 1 day ago
Yeah this is a perfect use case for torrents, could go a step further and keep track of a downloader’s ratio to stop people leaching.
YiddishMcSquidish@lemmy.today 1 day ago
Can things be fedirated and monetized so long as the monetization is put into maintenance & upkeep?
MouldyCat@feddit.uk 1 day ago
Nothing stopping you trying!
pulsewidth@lemmy.world 1 day ago
The Internet Archive. No need to reinvent the wheel. Have a discussion with them - set up a new project. Boom - everyone’s mods hosted in perpetuity by a free digital library.