Comment

Comment on Hexbear federation megathread

I find myself having conflicting thoughts about defederation in general.

Much of mainstream social media these days leads to isolation of ideologically-opposed communities from one another and pushes together more like-minded communities (“echo chamber”). I think that’s a bad thing.

I don’t find Hexbear’s culture a good fit for me, and though I share many of the same political sentiments, that’s why I’m using lemm.ee and not hexbear.

I would not enjoy it if a large group of alt-righters suddenly federated with us and became a very vocal presence, even if a large number of their users were often polite, because I am so strongly opposed to those politics.

How to balance between an “all or none” approach and avoid perpetuating an echo chamber? I’d say continue bolstering controls for individual users to decide and federate widely for now. The more visibility the instances have among each other, the more overall awareness there will be in the user base of which communities are truly bad actors vs. large, vocal, and a little immature.

source

Sort:hotnew top

420blazeit69@hexbear.net ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago
I would not enjoy it if a large group of alt-righters suddenly federated with us and became a very vocal presence, even if a large number of their users were often polite, because I am so strongly opposed to those politics.

There is a difference between occasionally annoying people who generally want good things and occasionally annoying people who generally want bad things. One example:

Alt-right opinions on immigrants in the U.S. range from “let’s immediately deport millions of people and create an even more deadly southern border” to "we should exterminate those [slurs]."

Hexbear opinions on the same subject range from “we should have an open border, a guaranteed minimum for all U.S. residents, and we should end the imperial meddling that causes so much immigration in the first place” to “yes and the imperial core owes untold sums in reparations to the Global South.”

Maybe you disagree with both, maybe you get annoyed by people talking about both, but one is fundamentally genocidal and the other is fundamentally humanistic.
source