I appreciate the post and your thoughtful reflections. I think I agree on your perspective: defederation should be the absolute last resort (at least for a “generalist” instance like ours, not specifically dedicated to a group of vulnerable people).

I’d like to see what the users of Hexbear have to say, even if I might not agree with them.

I’d say let’s keep them federated and see how things go. If resources permit it, mods should keep a watchful eye for propaganda and other unacceptable content.

Also, if users have the ability to block an instance (which is something I was not aware of), they should do it, if they so wish.

Again, thank you for your thoughtful message and for asking our opinion.