Comment on Labour is wilfully ignoring that the climate crisis is at a crunch point.
rah@feddit.uk 1 week agoYou’ve given me a list of nice-sounding ideas but no references whatsoever to demonstrate that what you’re saying is true.
Comment on Labour is wilfully ignoring that the climate crisis is at a crunch point.
rah@feddit.uk 1 week agoYou’ve given me a list of nice-sounding ideas but no references whatsoever to demonstrate that what you’re saying is true.
frankPodmore@slrpnk.net 1 week ago
I’m not especially keen on googling things for you, as it’s publicly available information which is easy to find. I think a better question, given that these are straightforward facts widely reported in both the mainstream and specialist press, is why you don’t think they’re doing anything.
rah@feddit.uk 1 week ago
For me? Wow. There was me thinking that providing well-sourced opinions was for the benefit of the writer in their not being dismissed out of hand.
Firstly, a majority of these links are to the same story reported in different publications. They give the impression that you searched the web for something like “labour green transition” and then copied all the URLs as links. I asked you what made you think that Labour have achieved anything, which is a question about you. I didn’t ask for help searching the web.
Secondly, none of the articles are about anything Labour has actually achieved, only what they say they’d like to do, are planning to do, or have done only as a result of procedures that were already in place when they took power. If these links are all you have then you have nothing convincing.
frankPodmore@slrpnk.net 1 week ago
I was asked to prove first that Labour are moving us away from oil dependence, and then that they are investing record breaking amounts, approving record numbers of green projects, that they have eased planning law to build more green infrastructure, and that they’re planning to do more.
The sources more than prove this. For example, when we have more solar power, we will be less dependent on oil. Labour are making this happen. I refer you again to the many different sources discussing other ways Labour are making this happen through the record investments that are also cited in the sources.
I acknowledged that there’s some repetition. One for each of the claims would suffice, but I added more because I felt that ‘record breaking’ is a bit vague (record for this country or for a fiscal year or…?) so I used more than one source to show that this was a valid interpretation of the facts.
Your latter critique, that all the sources discuss what Labour ‘will do’ is just false. Some of them do, of course - because that’s one of the things you asked me to prove.
I actually have a folder of saved tabs called ‘good things Labour are doing’ because I frequently have conversations with people determined to ignore these things. Could they do more? Yes, of course, and they should. Are they doing the things I’ve said they are doing? Yes.
rah@feddit.uk 1 week ago
I disagree.
Ah! So basically it’s just news articles on websites that have convinced you.