Comment on Proposal to create a collective to own the topic-based Lemmy instances
Grimy@lemmy.world 1 month agoJust coordinate the release of the urls and the transfer of the communties to someone elses hardware.
I’m skeptical about this since you wanted to bring blockchain subscription to lemmy a week ago and now you are squatting on 12 urls while trying to get volunteers to create value out of them. Nothing leads me to assume you are being altruistic.
It seems like you are waiting for the next influx to potentially monetize and trying to hold the most potential instances without putting any work or money into it. It’s just my impression.
I also think instances without users are a terrible idea.
rglullis@communick.news 1 month ago
This is exactly what I am offering. I want to transfer these instances to a consortium to own this collectively.
Just yesterday I renewed 10 of these domains. That cost me ~400€. I renewed nba.space and nfl.community last month, each cost ~650€. Running all these instances is costing me ~200€/month.
I’m not even looking to dump these costs on the potential new co-owners, this is why I said that I don’t mind keep running them.
First, we’d have to argue the implication. You are implying that any attempt at building anything that is financially sustainable is immoral, something that I said many times is completely misguided, and a point of view that is starting now to be shared by other prominent figures in the Fediverse.
Second, I am offering the instances to be co-owned precisely to assuage those concerns. By having other admins co-owning the instances, I’d hope that less people would be pushing those accusations against me.
Blaze@feddit.org 1 month ago
Thank you for providing the numbers, these domains are quite pricey if you have to pay 1700 € per year on domains alone.
rglullis@communick.news 1 month ago
Stop thinking in terms of prices, and start thinking in terms of value. A three-letter domain for less than 1000€ is a bargain.
Blaze@feddit.org 1 month ago
I’m thinking in terms of costs because those could prevent any admins potentially interested in joining you to do so.
Lemmy.ml still runs on a server which costs 80€ per month (lemmy.ml/comment/13507604). A .ml domain name costs 61€ per year on gandi.
Your hosting costs are 2.5x higher, your domain costs are 27 times higher.
Maybe you’ll find other admins who agree with you that it’s worth it.
mriormro@lemmy.world 1 month ago
You sound like a grifter.
Grimy@lemmy.world 1 month ago
So are you willing to give up ownership of the url and have the instance be transfered to someone else’s hardware?
Maybe I misunderstood where you are going with this.
rglullis@communick.news 1 month ago
To be precise, I’m willing to give up some ownership. I still want to participate in its governance.
If a new consortium is formed and if the collective decision is to move it, yes. If the decision is to keep as it is, also fine.