Comment on The Irony of 'You Wouldn't Download a Car' Making a Comeback in AI Debates
daellat@lemmy.world 1 week agoBecause the small thief in this example is not making money from the theft
Comment on The Irony of 'You Wouldn't Download a Car' Making a Comeback in AI Debates
daellat@lemmy.world 1 week agoBecause the small thief in this example is not making money from the theft
ContrarianTrail@lemm.ee 1 week ago
No, but they’re saving money which is effectively the same thing. There’s no practical difference between earning 50 bucks and getting a 50 buck discount.
keegomatic@lemmy.world 1 week ago
That’s not quite true, though, is it?
$50 earned is yours to spend on anything. A $50 discount is offered by a vendor to entice you to spend enough of your money on them to make the discount worthwhile.
Pirates don’t pirate because they’re trying to save money on something they would have bought otherwise… typically they pirate because the amount they consume would bankrupt them if they purchased it through legitimate means, so they would never have been a paying customer in the first place.
So, if they wouldn’t have bought it anyway, and they’re not reselling it, did they really harm the vendor? Whether they pirated it or not, it wouldn’t affect the vendor either way.
That’s not really the same thing, in my opinion.
If you were able to pay for everything handily but pirated anyway, or if you resold pirated content, then yeah you have something similar to theft going on. But that’s not really the norm; those people are doing something bad irrespective of the piracy itself, aren’t they?
ContrarianTrail@lemm.ee 1 week ago
They wouldn’t have bought all the content they have pirated if piracy was not an option but they would have bought some of it.
Piracy has saves money. Saving money means I have more money to spend on other things. Earning money means I have more money to spend on other things. There’s no practical difference between the two.
In my view, my point still stands; being against one but not the other is hypocritical.
keegomatic@lemmy.world 1 week ago
It’s not hypocritical if you believe that theft is wrong because it hurts another person, rather than wrong because you don’t deserve the thing or that it offers you an unfair advantage. Your argument leans heavily on the latter but mine the former.